I have tried Loreal Voluminous and its a no go. The Tarte Amazonian Clay eyeliner stays put, but I am having a hard time finding a mascara that I can go to the lake or swim in. How is the Tarte? Any other suggestions?
I've tried any waterproof mascara that I find and just about any "waterproof" will do the job - but make sure it says waterproof. Tarte is not called waterproof. Mally had a waterproof mascara in a pink tube. Maybeline has many good ones also. At times I mix mascaras both regular and waterproof depending on how my eyelashes look when applying. I always start with a waterproof and the last coat is always waterproof. I have such short skimpy lashes that many coats are needed. Merely waterresistant will come off while swimming.
I've been using Lancome's Definicils in Waterproof and Maybelline XXL, the one with the primer and both have worked great this summer! HTH!
Cover Girl Professional waterproof mascara works very well.
Lately I have been loving Urban Decay's cannonball. I also swear by Diorshow waterproof.
I have a fever . . . and the only cure . . . is more COWBELL!
I really like Bare escentuals flawless definition waterproof. I always use that as my first coat because it holds curl really well, it also never clumps or flakes on me. It's easy to remove as well
Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof mascara (pink tube) is truly waterproof.
I have used Clinique waterproof mascara and I know it is tear proof and I definitely had to remove it with a product.
Mally in the pink tube is pretty darn tough!!!
The one I swear by for swimming is Laura Geller's At Long Lash mascara. You can only take it off with an oil based remover - you can wash your face with soap and this mascara will stay put!
I have to agree with Sandy53 on the Covergirl Professionals (blue tube).
Mac Zoom Waterproof is waterproof to the point of being annoying.
I like Cover Girl Lash Blast. If you try it, make sure you get the waterproof version as they make both!